1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.
  2. If you had a PIAF Forum account in the vBulletin days, log in with your old credentials. Otherwise, sign up again and we'll get you back in business as soon as we can.
  3. A serious FreePBX vulnerability has been reported. Update your Framework Module immediately. Click here for details.

TIPS What's a good router for PIAF?

Discussion in 'Open Discussion' started by Dale Fredrikson, Dec 18, 2009.

  1. nightstryke Member

    Yet again, this is why I use my own system (Untangle.)
    magna.vis likes this.
  2. quintont New Member

    My ISP just gave me a new modem - http://smartrg.com/products/products/sr350n/ - all phones connect to the pbx but can't make/receive calls. No dial tone. Putting one of the extensions on the DMZ does nothing. Yet, I have my Samsung S3 with zoiper app make and receive calls fine over wifi fine via the same modem.
    Running Travellin Man 3 / PIAF Green / RentPBX.com
    Any ideas?
  3. rossiv Guru

    What kind of phones are you using, @quintont ?
  4. atsak Guru

    I wonder if it's polycom? I have had trouble with multiple polycom's behind routers other than Tomato . . .
  5. quintont New Member

    Hi - thanks for the response. - yes, I'm running polycom 320 phones. Going to try to plug in my old grandstream 2000 now. The Polycom's were running fine on the old modem. (took it back to the isp so I don't know the model).
  6. quintont New Member

    No luck with the Grandstream. It does get further, and connects, but no sound. Still on the DMZ. Samsung S3 still working fine.
  7. rjaiswal Moderator

    Couple of questions... Do you have nat=yes on your extensions? And in the asterisk cli, when you do a sip show peers, do you see your external address or the phones internal address?
  8. atsak Guru

    You can probably fix this by buying an inexpensive router and loading Tomato (the ASUS RT16 or something); the Polycom's will work behind that. Put the SmartRG into bridge mode. You can likely make it work with the Smart but it might take a lot of work / time. Might not be worth it.
  9. Hyksos Guru

    Nobody realized it but the OP has hijacked a thread and not just any thread... This does not belong here... at all...
    Just saying...
  10. quintont New Member

    Hyksos - The thread, 'What's a good router for PIAF' is within the General Discussion category, which is what we're doing - generally discussing. I agree that perhaps now that its been established that the SmartRG is not a good router that the discussion could be taken elsewhere, although you make no suggestion of where to take that post, nor any constructive comment on the SmartRG. You've done the virtual equivalent of walking into a meeting, saying "you're all full of crap", and walking out again. Thank you to all who have provided input. I'm going shopping for a new box. If anyone has any suggestions on how to get the SmartRG to work for my fixed line phones, I'd like to learn more. I'll be trying the suggestions above and if there's no progress, will move on to new hardware. Thanks again.
  11. Hyksos Guru

    You feel attacked for nothing, you should have started a thread that's all I'm saying. It belongs in a new thread specific to your specific question, that's all.

    You're generally discussing your specific issue, not generally discussing good routers for PIAF.
    Check the answers/questions you got, help for your question, you would be better served in your own thread under "Help" with a subject line like the name of your new modem...
    Any of those guys would have told you it should go in a new thread, they just wanted to help so much that they didn't realize it this time.

    But that's an opinion and it's mine you can disagree without feeling attacked.
    It's like if I entered a meeting room and said you're all full of crap cuz you're sitting in the janitor's office! and then... I left.
    MGD4me likes this.
  12. quintont New Member

    thanks rjaiswal - NAT=yes on the extensions fixed the issue. SmartRG sr350n works now.
  13. magna.vis Guru

    SOLD OUT! This is on sale again, now $5 after MIR. I got this MIR back in just a few weeks, ASUS's MIR program comes highly recommended from me. Updated links:

    Product: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Asus-RT-N10P
    Promo Code:EMCPEWE42
    $10 MIR, link on product page. Still supports Tomato, and mine has been running strong since December, 2013. For $5, this is a great router to have in a pinch, or for temporary use while troubleshooting or testing new features.
    Last edited by magna.vis, May 15, 2014

Share This Page